Xbox 360 vs PS3... The Final Showdown.

Share your opinions and questions about anything to do with gaming and technology.

Moderator: Forum Guards

Postby Siva » Mon Nov 12, 07 9:13 pm

It was the Xbox.

The GC 1.5 thing was from the original rumours seeded by the whole "two gamecubes taped together" thing.

The Wii actually has the power graphically of two Gamecubes.
//..
User avatar
Siva
doesn't care about augmented people
 
Posts: 6757
Joined: Tue Dec 06, 05 4:56 pm

Postby James » Mon Nov 12, 07 9:16 pm

SPECS, SHOW.
I am dead.
User avatar
James
Alpha
 
Posts: 28885
Joined: Sun Oct 26, 03 9:14 pm
Location: Home

Postby Siva » Mon Nov 12, 07 9:23 pm

One moment.

Code: Select all
General

    * Name
    * Nintendo Wii

    * Type
    * Game console

    * Height
    * 1.75 in

    * Weight
    * 3.84 lbs

Game Console

    * Color Support
    * Color

    * Media Type
    * Nintendo Wii disc, Nintendo GAMECUBE disc

Processor

    * Type
    * IBM PowerPC

    * Instruction Set
    * RISC

Memory / Storage

    * RAM Installed ( Max )
    * 512 MB

    * Cartridge Memory
    * RAM:

Memory Card

    * Type
    * Flash

    * Storage Capacity
    * 512 MB

Video

    * Video Output
    * ATI Hollywood

Communications

    * Connectivity Features
    * IEEE 802.11

Input Device

    * Type
    * Joystick, Remote control

    * Connectivity Technology
    * Wired, Wireless

    * Features
    * Motion sensor, Rumble feedback, Built-in speaker

Connections

    * Connector Type
    * ( 4 pin USB Type A), 4 x Game controller), x Component video output), x Composite video output), x S-Video output)

    * Expansion Slots Total (Free)
    * 2 Nintendo GameCube Memory Card, 1 SD Memory Card

Code: Select all
General

    * Name
    * Nintendo GAMECUBE

    * Type
    * Game console

    * Width
    * 5.9 in

    * Depth
    * 6.3 in

    * Height
    * 4.3 in

    * Weight
    * 5.3 lbs

    * Enclosure Color
    * Black

Game Console

    * Color Support
    * Color

    * Media Type
    * Nintendo GAMECUBE disc

Processor

    * Type
    * IBM PowerPC "Gekko" 485 MHz

    * Installed Qty
    * 1

    * Instruction Set
    * X86-to-RISC

    * Data Width
    * 64 bit

Memory / Storage

    * RAM Installed ( Max )
    * 24 KB1T-SRAM - Integrated

    * Cache Memory
    * 256 KB Write-Back

    * Cartridge Memory
    * RAM:

    * Storage
    * Nintendo GAMECUBE drive - 1.5 GB - Top-load

Display

    * Type
    * None.

Video

    * Video Output
    * ATI Flipper - 64-bit - 2D/3D graphics acceleration

    * Video Memory Installed ( Max )
    * Shared video memory (UMA) - Integrated

    * Graphic Effects
    * Shadows, Fog effects, MIP-mapping, Bump mapping, Anti-aliasing, Alpha-blending, Texture lighting, Bilinear filtering, Trilinear filtering, Anisotropic filtering, Texture compression (S3TC)

    * Max Resolution (external)
    * 32-bit color

    * Supported Video
    * HF TV signal, Component video, Composite video

Audio

    * Audio Processor
    * ATI Flipper 81 MHz

    * Sound Output Mode
    * 16-bit / Stereo

    * Sound Memory
    * 16 KB

    * Max Sample Rate
    * 48 KHz

Communications

    * Modem
    * None

Input Device

    * Type
    * Game pad - External - 8button(s)

    * Connectivity Technology
    * Wired

    * Movement Detection Technology
    * Mechanical

    * Pointing Device / Manipulator
    * 8-way hat switch, 4-way cross keypad

Connections

    * Connector Type
    * 1 x GameCube AV output ( GameCube digital AV connector), 1 x GameCube AV output ( GameCube analog AV output), 4 x Game controller)

    * Expansion Slots Total (Free)
    * 2 ( 2 ) x Memory, 3 ) x Expansion slot

Power

    * Power Device
    * Power adapter - External

    * Battery
    * None

Manufacturer Warranty

    * Service & Support
    * 1 year warranty

Code: Select all
General

    * Name
    * Xbox

    * Type
    * Game console

    * Width
    * 11.8 in

    * Depth
    * 7.1 in

    * Height
    * 3.1 in

    * Weight
    * 8.8 lbs

    * Enclosure Color
    * Black

    * Enclosure Material
    * Plastic

    * Localization
    * English / North America

Game Console

    * Color Support
    * Color

    * Media Type
    * DVD-ROM

Processor

    * Type
    * Intel Pentium III 733 MHz

    * Installed Qty
    * 1

    * Instruction Set
    * X86-to-RISC

Memory / Storage

    * RAM Installed ( Max )
    * 64 MB ( 64 MB )DDR SDRAM - Integrated

    * Cache Memory
    * 128 KB Advanced Transfer Cache

    * Cartridge Memory
    * RAM:

    * Storage
    * DVD-ROM 5x - 8 GB - Tray

    * Hard Disk Drive
    * Yes

    * HDD Capacity
    * 8 GB

Memory Card

    * Type
    * Flash

    * Storage Capacity
    * 8 MB

    * Color
    * Black

Display

    * Type
    * None.

Video

    * Video Output
    * NVIDIA Xbox GPU - 256-bit - 2D/3D graphics acceleration

    * Operating Performance
    * 116.5 MIPS

    * Fill Rate
    * 4000 million pixels/sec

    * Video Memory Installed ( Max )
    * Shared video memory (UMA) - Integrated

    * Graphic Effects
    * Shadows, Fog effects, Pixel Shaders, Vertex Shaders, Texture lighting, Bilinear filtering, Trilinear filtering

    * Max Resolution (external)
    * 32-bit color / 1920 x 1080

    * Supported Video
    * NTSC - S-Video, - Component video, - Composite video

Audio

    * Audio Processor
    * NVIDIA Xbox MCP

    * Sound Output Mode
    * Stereo

Communications

    * Modem
    * - Integrated

    * Max Transfer Rate
    * 100 Mbps

Input Device

    * Type
    * Game pad - External - 8button(s)

    * Connectivity Technology
    * Wired

    * Movement Detection Technology
    * Mechanical

Connections

    * Connector Type
    * 1 x Xbox AV output ( Xbox AV connector), 4 x Game controller), 1 x Network ( RJ-45)

    * Expansion Slots Total (Free)
    * 2 ( 2 ) x Memory

Power

    * Power Device
    * Power supply - Integrated

    * Power
    * ± 10% ( 60 Hz)

    * Power Consumption Operational
    * 100 Watt

    * Battery
    * None

Manufacturer Warranty

    * Service & Support
    * 1 year warranty

    * Service & Support Details
    * Limited warranty - Parts and labor - 1 year

Code: Select all
Hollywood is the name of the Graphics Processing Unit (GPU) used in Nintendo's Wii video game console. It was designed by ATI Technologies and is manufactured with the same 90 nm CMOS process[1] as the "Broadway" processor. Very few official details have been released to the public by Nintendo, ATI, or IBM. Unofficial reports claim it is essentially an enhanced revision of the Nintendo GameCube LSI "Flipper", and was reportedly clocked at 243 MHz, but none of the clock rates have been confirmed by Nintendo, IBM, or ATI. It is also unknown how many pixel pipelines or shader units Hollywood possesses.[2]

The Hollywood is a Multi-Chip Module package composed of two dies within the cover. One of the two chips, codenamed Napa, controls the I/O functions, RAM access, and the actual GPU with its 3 MiB of embedded texture memory, and measures 8 × 9 mm. The other, codenamed Vegas, holds the Audio DSP and the 24 MiB of "internal" 1T-SRAM and measures 13.5 × 7 mm. Hollywood has a 128-Bit memory interface between the VRAM and GPU.[3]


Also, here is the article that I read the Wii has double the pixel pipelines of the Gamecube.

Code: Select all
EN: Could you possibly tell us anything specific about the Wii GPU?
XP: I can tell you that it has double the number of pixel pipelines (of gamecube), and that it processes physics. It really takes a huge load off of the cpu.


http://www.rage3d.com/board/showthread.php?t=33857367

The Xbox chip is usually referred to as a GeForce 3.5, (google this one), and if you look at this part of the article --
Code: Select all
EN: How about the Wii hardware? What are the specs?
XP: Although i cannot give you exact numbers at this time i can give you a rough idea about the power of the machine. I would compare the graphics chip to somewhere inbetween the ATI Radeon X1400 and the Radeon X1600, and the CPU to between the AthlonXP 2400+ and the AthlonXP 3000+.

EN: Can you tell us how much memory at what speed the Wii has?
XP: I cannot say how much memory the Wii has, but its running at 650mhz.

EN: As we saw in many current-gen titles, 480p can result in significant jaggies. Can we expect AA and AF from Ubisoft's Wii titles?
XP: Red steel will have 4x Antialiasing and 8x Anisotropic Filtering.

EN: What's been your favorite thing about working on Red Steel?
XP: The controller, easily.

EN: What was the biggest challenge?
XP: Not telling the world about it back in january (laughs). Honestly the biggest challenge has been making sure the control is just right.

EN: Will Rayman on the Wii be a port of the current-gen game with new controls, or will it have new art assets for Wii?
XP: Its not a port, other than that i cannot say.

EN: We've been hearing a lot of consistent talk about 60fps at 480p widescreen from other developers. Is this something we'll see a lot of on Wii?
XP: I believe so yes.


Particularly at the beginning, it is compared to a X1500 of sorts, and if you look at somewhere like Tom's hardware, you can see that an X1600 is slightly below the 6800 and above the 6600. So in nVidia terms it would be compared to a 6700 if it existed.
Last edited by Siva on Mon Nov 12, 07 9:39 pm, edited 4 times in total.
//..
User avatar
Siva
doesn't care about augmented people
 
Posts: 6757
Joined: Tue Dec 06, 05 4:56 pm

Postby C:Enter:£££ » Mon Nov 12, 07 10:07 pm

XII//:Protocol wrote:
LTKJAY wrote:
Baleout wrote:Wii has the same power as a PS2 / Gamecube?


Wii is practically the same as the Gamecube, TP are identical on both consoles. :roll:


Retro Stated that the Gamecube could not handle Metroid Prime 3.

And when the Wii specs were released, it boiled down to about 1.5x the power of the original Xbox.

AAAAAND, the Xbox was the strongest console in terms of hardware last gen.


The Xbox1 is a motherfucking BEAST! Love that thing.
User avatar
C:Enter:£££
Forum Legend
 
Posts: 5916
Joined: Mon Dec 08, 03 10:38 pm
Location: Yorkshire

Postby Baleout » Tue Nov 13, 07 1:02 am

LTKJAY wrote:
Baleout wrote:Wii has the same power as a PS2 / Gamecube?


Wii is practically the same as the Gamecube, TP are identical on both consoles. :roll:

That is because it is easier to have an identical game with a few control changes and mirror it than to re-do the graphics of the whole thing to fully take avantage of the Wii, delaying the game YET AGAIN.
User avatar
Baleout
Master
 
Posts: 1606
Joined: Mon Feb 19, 07 1:28 pm
Location: Greater London

Postby Allan » Thu Nov 15, 07 9:25 pm

LTKJAY wrote:All consoles heat up, lol, my PS2 burnt more than my Xbox.


My old SCPH-50003 model actually caught on fire. Now I can't play Guitar Hero until I get another one, and it'll have to be the shitty slimline version... X_X
User avatar
Allan
Alpha
 
Posts: 4545
Joined: Wed Dec 21, 05 1:41 pm
Location: Northamptonshire, England.

Postby Tonnochi » Thu Nov 15, 07 10:00 pm

Think they have enough cash or balls to make a slim PS3? Scale it down so it's the size of a sedan maybe?
User avatar
Tonnochi
Forum Hero
 
Posts: 2719
Joined: Mon May 28, 07 11:43 pm

Postby Allan » Thu Nov 15, 07 10:20 pm

[FGS]Zeitgeist wrote:Think they have enough cash or balls to make a slim PS3? Scale it down so it's the size of a sedan maybe?


Cash: Yes. But not for long at this rate. Needs more games.
Balls: Not for a while yet.
Size down to a sedan: Sounds good to me. Will look forward to it. :D
User avatar
Allan
Alpha
 
Posts: 4545
Joined: Wed Dec 21, 05 1:41 pm
Location: Northamptonshire, England.

Postby Siva » Fri Nov 16, 07 2:01 pm

Allan got them the wrong way around.
//..
User avatar
Siva
doesn't care about augmented people
 
Posts: 6757
Joined: Tue Dec 06, 05 4:56 pm

Postby Allan » Fri Nov 16, 07 3:07 pm

XII//:Protocol wrote:Allan got them the wrong way around.
Ah, good point.
User avatar
Allan
Alpha
 
Posts: 4545
Joined: Wed Dec 21, 05 1:41 pm
Location: Northamptonshire, England.

Postby Dae » Sun Feb 24, 08 2:24 pm

I decided to buy PS3.

Please tell me, does it have to be connected to the internet, if I bring the games with myself and I don't intend to play the multiplayer? In the place where PS3 will be installed the internet traffic is quite expensive.
User avatar
Dae
Alpha
 
Posts: 12086
Joined: Sat Sep 06, 03 4:40 pm

Postby Siva » Sun Feb 24, 08 2:46 pm

NO DAE

DON'T GO INTO THE FIRE.

Also, the PS3 never has to be connected to the internet unless you intend on using the PlayStation Network.
//..
User avatar
Siva
doesn't care about augmented people
 
Posts: 6757
Joined: Tue Dec 06, 05 4:56 pm

Postby James » Sun Feb 24, 08 3:06 pm

Dae[A] wrote:I decided to buy PS3.

Please tell me, does it have to be connected to the internet, if I bring the games with myself and I don't intend to play the multiplayer? In the place where PS3 will be installed the internet traffic is quite expensive.


You won't have games to play anyway.
I am dead.
User avatar
James
Alpha
 
Posts: 28885
Joined: Sun Oct 26, 03 9:14 pm
Location: Home

Postby Dae » Sun Feb 24, 08 6:40 pm

I just found out there is black version of Xbox360, called Elite (color matters for my parents...)

At the same time I read on Wikipedia that elite has been discontinued (although its sold in the nearest shop) and its old, etc. True/false?

How good Xbox 360 is with HDTVs of 50"+?

Also, now about Xbox360:
Dae[A] wrote:does it have to be connected to the internet, if I bring the games with myself and I don't intend to play the multiplayer?
User avatar
Dae
Alpha
 
Posts: 12086
Joined: Sat Sep 06, 03 4:40 pm

Postby Jon » Sun Feb 24, 08 6:58 pm

no
User avatar
Jon
Alpha
 
Posts: 1081
Joined: Mon Dec 12, 05 10:20 pm
Location: Derbyshire, England

Postby Spiderbot01 » Sun Feb 24, 08 7:50 pm

I have the elite.

It is win.
<center>------</center><center>
Image</center>
<center>Image</center><
User avatar
Spiderbot01
Alpha
 
Posts: 5363
Joined: Wed Nov 30, 05 8:24 pm
Location: LONDON!!!!

Postby xProtocol Rain » Sun Feb 24, 08 8:10 pm

Why in Gods name is this thread revived?
Image
Image
xProtocol Rain
Death and Destruction
 
Posts: 1995
Joined: Sun Aug 28, 05 9:54 pm
Location: Georgia (the 'states)

Postby Snakey » Sun Feb 24, 08 9:26 pm

Dae[A] wrote:I just found out there is black version of Xbox360, called Elite (color matters for my parents...)

At the same time I read on Wikipedia that elite has been discontinued (although its sold in the nearest shop) and its old, etc. True/false?

How good Xbox 360 is with HDTVs of 50"+?

Also, now about Xbox360:
Dae[A] wrote:does it have to be connected to the internet, if I bring the games with myself and I don't intend to play the multiplayer?


It is the Core version that has been discontinued.
<center>

Image
User avatar
Snakey
Alpha
 
Posts: 3926
Joined: Wed Mar 30, 05 7:09 pm
Location: Wales

Postby clyzm » Sun Feb 24, 08 10:18 pm

[A]boveTheLaw wrote:I have the elite.

It is win.


^ same

On a totally unrelated note, your GT ENKIDU, isn't that the enemy of GILGAMESH?
Image
User avatar
clyzm
Forum Master God
 
Posts: 16023
Joined: Sun Nov 28, 04 2:48 am
Location: Chiraq

Postby Dae » Mon Feb 25, 08 1:27 am

After watching some screenies and gathering information I decided to stop on XBox 360 Elite.

+ I can play Forza 2, Gears of War and many other exclusive games on it
+ It has a bigger community in Russia than PS3
+ A lot of games can be downloaded (I will download only if there is no localized legal version)

- It looks worse than PS3 (on photos at least, haven't seen in reality yet)
- It doesn't support 1080p (only 1080i)
- It doesn't have blu-ray
- It can't run Ubuntu Linux (only special Xbox Linux which requires some hardware modifying?)

Looking forward to buying the first console in my life :P
User avatar
Dae
Alpha
 
Posts: 12086
Joined: Sat Sep 06, 03 4:40 pm

Postby clyzm » Mon Feb 25, 08 2:04 am

Dae[A] wrote:After watching some screenies and gathering information I decided to stop on XBox 360 Elite.

+ I can play Forza 2, Gears of War and many other exclusive games on it
+ It has a bigger community in Russia than PS3
+ A lot of games can be downloaded (I will download only if there is no localized legal version)

- It looks worse than PS3 (on photos at least, haven't seen in reality yet)
- It doesn't support 1080p (only 1080i)
- It doesn't have blu-ray
- It can't run Ubuntu Linux (only special Xbox Linux which requires some hardware modifying?)

Looking forward to buying the first console in my life :P


Bad decision m8.

But hey, if you're gonna buy the first console game of your life, make it CoD4 :P
Last edited by clyzm on Mon Feb 25, 08 2:05 am, edited 1 time in total.
Image
User avatar
clyzm
Forum Master God
 
Posts: 16023
Joined: Sun Nov 28, 04 2:48 am
Location: Chiraq

Postby James » Mon Feb 25, 08 2:08 am

cataclyzm wrote:
[A]boveTheLaw wrote:I have the elite.

It is win.


^ same

On a totally unrelated note, your GT ENKIDU, isn't that the enemy of GILGAMESH?


ENKIDUDU is after a mech that is indeed based on ENKI & ENKIDU, rode by a man who is also related to beasts.

You know whats the funniest thing, search for Enkidudu on myspace for the first result.
Last edited by James on Mon Feb 25, 08 2:08 am, edited 1 time in total.
I am dead.
User avatar
James
Alpha
 
Posts: 28885
Joined: Sun Oct 26, 03 9:14 pm
Location: Home

Postby clyzm » Mon Feb 25, 08 4:23 am

LTKJAY wrote:
cataclyzm wrote:
[A]boveTheLaw wrote:I have the elite.

It is win.


^ same

On a totally unrelated note, your GT ENKIDU, isn't that the enemy of GILGAMESH?


ENKIDUDU is after a mech that is indeed based on ENKI & ENKIDU, rode by a man who is also related to beasts.

You know whats the funniest thing, search for Enkidudu on myspace for the first result.


Haha, Max is the first one.

Interesting, I was reading up on Gilgamesh and is told he controlled Enkidu with a prostitute that made him more relaxed. 8)
Image
User avatar
clyzm
Forum Master God
 
Posts: 16023
Joined: Sun Nov 28, 04 2:48 am
Location: Chiraq

Postby Dae » Mon Feb 25, 08 10:24 am

cataclyzm wrote:Bad decision m8.

Why bad? I've chosen XBox :?
User avatar
Dae
Alpha
 
Posts: 12086
Joined: Sat Sep 06, 03 4:40 pm

Postby Alex » Mon Feb 25, 08 1:37 pm

Dae[A] wrote:
cataclyzm wrote:Bad decision m8.

Why bad? I've chosen XBox :?

Choose Wii.
Alex
Alpha
 
Posts: 8067
Joined: Wed Nov 12, 03 4:51 pm

Postby James » Mon Feb 25, 08 1:55 pm

Dae[A] wrote:
cataclyzm wrote:Bad decision m8.

Why bad? I've chosen XBox :?


I don't know if you remember but the failure rate of the 360 is annoying, and I doubt there is repair service in Russia, however, just make sure its always placed horizontal.
I am dead.
User avatar
James
Alpha
 
Posts: 28885
Joined: Sun Oct 26, 03 9:14 pm
Location: Home

Postby Siva » Mon Feb 25, 08 2:06 pm

Damnit Dae, choose your PC.
//..
User avatar
Siva
doesn't care about augmented people
 
Posts: 6757
Joined: Tue Dec 06, 05 4:56 pm

Postby clyzm » Mon Feb 25, 08 2:24 pm

Dae[A] wrote:
cataclyzm wrote:Bad decision m8.

Why bad? I've chosen XBox :?


"stop on the x360"

I thought it means "stop choosing the x360" instead of choosing it, also you listed more cons than pros.

Sorry if I misunderstood :P X360 ftw
Last edited by clyzm on Mon Feb 25, 08 2:25 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Image
User avatar
clyzm
Forum Master God
 
Posts: 16023
Joined: Sun Nov 28, 04 2:48 am
Location: Chiraq

Postby Siva » Mon Feb 25, 08 2:31 pm

PC HAS NO CONS
//..
User avatar
Siva
doesn't care about augmented people
 
Posts: 6757
Joined: Tue Dec 06, 05 4:56 pm

Postby clyzm » Mon Feb 25, 08 2:32 pm

XII//:Protocol wrote:PC HAS NO CONS


LOL UPGRADES WHATS THAT
Image
User avatar
clyzm
Forum Master God
 
Posts: 16023
Joined: Sun Nov 28, 04 2:48 am
Location: Chiraq

PreviousNext

Return to Gaming and Technology

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 7 guests